The Penguin critics vie with one another in affirming that Penguin art
has from its origin been distinguished by a powerful and pleasing
originality, and that we may look elsewhere in vain for the qualities
of grace and reason that characterise its earliest works. But the
Porpoises claim that their artists were undoubtedly the instructors and
masters of the Penguins. It is difficult to form an opinion on the
matter, because the Penguins, before they began to admire their
primitive painters, destroyed all their works.
We cannot be too sorry for this loss. For my own part I feel it
cruelly, for I venerate the Penguin antiquities and I adore the
primitives. They are delightful. I do not say the are all alike, for
that would be untrue, but they have common characters that are found in
all schools—I mean formulas from which they never depart—and there is
besides something finished in their work, for what they know they know
well. Luckily we can form a notion of the Penguin primitives from the
Italian, Flemish, and Dutch primitives, and from the French primitives,
who are superior to all the rest; as M. Gruyer tells us they are more
logical, logic being a peculiarly French quality. Even if this is
denied it must at least be admitted that to France belongs the credit
of having kept primitives when the other nations knew them no longer.
The Exhibition of French Primitives at the Pavilion Marsan in 1904
contained several little panels contemporary with the later Valois
kings and with Henry IV.
I have made many journeys to see the pictures of the brothers Van Eyck,
of Memling, of Roger van der Weyden, of the painter of the death of
Mary, of Ambrogio Lorenzetti, and of the old Umbrian masters. It was,
however, neither Bruges, nor Cologne, nor Sienna, nor Perugia, that
completed my initiation; it was in the little town of Arezzo that I
became a conscious adept in primitive painting. That was ten years ago
or even longer. At that period of indigence and simplicity, the
municipal museums, though usually kept shut, were always opened to
foreigners. One evening an old woman with a candle showed me, for half
a lira, the sordid museum of Arezzo, and in it I discovered a painting
by Margaritone, a “St. Francis,” the pious sadness of which moved me to
tears. I was deeply touched, and Margaritone, of Arezzo became from
that day my dearest primitive.
I picture to myself the Penguin primitives in conformity with the works
of that master. It will not therefore be thought superfluous if in this
place I consider his works with some attention, if not in detail, at
least under their more general and, if I dare say so, most
representative aspect.
We possess five or six pictures signed with his hand. His masterpiece,
preserved in the National Gallery of London, represents the Virgin
seated on a throne and holding the infant Jesus in her arms. What
strikes one first when one looks at this figure is the proportion. The
body from the neck to the feet is only twice as long as the head, so
that it appears extremely short and podgy. This work is not less
remarkable for its painting than for its drawing. The great Margaritone
had but a limited number of colours in his possession, and he used them
in all their purity without ever modifying the tones. From this it
follows that his colouring has more vivacity than harmony. The cheeks
of the Virgin and those of the Child are of a bright vermilion which
the old master, from a naïve preference for clear definitions, has
placed on each face in two circumferences as exact as if they had been
traced out by a pair of compasses.
A learned critic of the eighteenth century, the Abbé Lanzi, has treated
Margaritone’s works with profound disdain. “They are,” he says, “merely
crude daubs. In those unfortunate times people could neither draw nor
paint.” Such was the common opinion of the connoisseurs of the days of
powdered wigs. But the great Margaritone and his contemporaries were
soon to be avenged for this cruel contempt. There was born in the
nineteenth century, in the biblical villages and reformed cottages of
pious England, a multitude of little Samuels and little St. Johns, with
hair curling like lambs, who, about 1840, and 1850, became spectacled
professors and founded the cult of the primitives.
That eminent theorist of Pre-Raphaelitism, Sir James Tuckett, does not
shrink from placing the Madonna of the National Gallery on a level with
the masterpieces of Christian art. “By giving to the Virgin’s head,”
says Sir James Tuckett, “a third of the total height of the figure, the
old master attracts the spectator’s attention and keeps it directed
towards the more sublime parts of the human figure, and in particular
the eyes, which we ordinarily describe as the spiritual organs. In this
picture, colouring and design conspire to produce an ideal and mystical
impression. The vermilion of the cheeks does not recall the natural
appearance of the skin; it rather seems as if the old master has
applied the roses of Paradise to the faces of the Mother and the
Child.”
We see, in such a criticism as this, a shining reflection, so to speak,
of the work which it exalts; yet MacSilly, the seraphic aesthete of
Edinburgh, has expressed in a still more moving and penetrating fashion
the impression produced upon his mind by the sight of this primitive
painting. “The Madonna of Margaritone,” says the revered MacSilly,
“attains the transcendent end of art. It inspires its beholders with
feelings of innocence and purity; it makes them like little children.
And so true is this, that at the age of sixty-six, after having had the
joy of contemplating it closely for three hours, I felt myself suddenly
transformed into a little child. While my cab was taking me through
Trafalgar Square I kept laughing and prattling and shaking my
spectacle-case as if it were a rattle. And when the maid in my
boarding-house had served my meal I kept pouring spoonfuls of soup into
my ear with all the artlessness of childhood.”
“It is by such results,” adds MacSilly, “that the excellence of a work
of art is proved.”
Margaritone, according to Vasari, died at the age of seventy-seven,
“regretting that he had lived to see a new form of art arising and the
new artists crowned with fame.”
These lines, which I translate literally, have inspired Sir James
Tuckett with what are perhaps the finest pages in his work. They form
part of his “Breviary for Æsthetes”; all the Pre-Raphaelites know them
by heart. I place them here as the most precious ornament of this book.
You will agree that nothing more sublime has been written since the
days of the Hebrew prophets.
MARGARITONE’S VISION
Margaritone, full of years and labours, went one day to visit the
studio of a young painter who had lately settled in the town. He
noticed in the studio a freshly painted Madonna, which, although severe
and rigid, nevertheless, by a certain exactness in the proportions and
a devilish mingling of light and shade, assumed an appearance of relief
and life. At this sight the artless and sublime worker of Arezzo
perceived with horror what the future of painting would be. With his
brow clasped in his hands he exclaimed:
“What things of shame does not this figure show forth! I discern in it
the end of that Christian art which paints the soul and inspires the
beholder with an ardent desire for heaven. Future painters will not
restrain themselves as does this one to portraying on the side of a
wall or on a wooden panel the cursed matter of which our bodies are
formed; they will celebrate and glorify it. They will clothe their
figures with dangerous appearances of flesh, and these figures will
seem like real persons. Their bodies will be seen; their forms will
appear through their clothing. St. Magdalen will have a bosom. St.
Martha a belly, St. Barbara hips, St. Agnes buttocks; St. Sebastian
will unveil his youthful beauty, and St. George will display beneath
his armour the muscular wealth of a robust virility; apostles,
confessors, doctors, and God the Father himself will appear as ordinary
beings like you and me; the angels will affect an equivocal, ambiguous,
mysterious beauty which will trouble hearts. What desire for heaven
will these representations impart? None; but from them you will learn
to take pleasure in the forms of terrestrial life. Where will painters
stop in their indiscreet inquiries? They will stop nowhere. They will
go so far as to show men and women naked like the idols of the Romans.
There will be a sacred art and a profane art, and the sacred art will
not be less profane than the other.”
“Get ye behind me, demons,” exclaimed the old master. For in prophetic
vision he saw the righteous and the saints assuming the appearance of
melancholy athletes. He saw Apollos playing the lute on a flowery hill,
in the midst of the Muses wearing light tunics. He saw Venuses lying
under shady myrtles and the Danae exposing their charming sides to the
golden rain. He saw pictures of Jesus under the pillars of the temple
amidst patricians, fair ladies, musicians, pages, negroes, dogs, and
parrots. He saw in an inextricable confusion of human limbs, outspread
wings, and flying draperies, crowds of tumultuous Nativities, opulent
Holy Families, emphatic Crucifixions. He saw St. Catherines, St.
Barbaras, St. Agneses humiliating patricians by the sumptuousness of
their velvets, their brocades, and their pearls, and by the splendour
of their breasts. He saw Auroras scattering roses, and a multitude of
naked Dianas and Nymphs surprised on the banks of retired streams. And
the great Margaritone died, strangled by so horrible a presentiment of
the Renaissance and the Bolognese School.
VI. MARBODIUS
We possess a precious monument of the Penguin literature of the
fifteenth century. It is a narrative of a journey to hell undertaken by
the monk Marbodius, of the order of St. Benedict, who professed a
fervent admiration for the poet Virgil. This narrative, written in
fairly good Latin, has been published by M. du Clos des Limes. It is
here translated for the first time. I believe that I am doing a service
to my fellow-countrymen in making them acquainted with these pages,
though doubtless they are far from forming a unique example of this
class of mediaeval Latin literature. Among the fictions that may be
compared with them we may mention “The Voyage of St. Brendan,” “The
Vision of Albericus,” and “St. Patrick’s Purgatory,” imaginary
descriptions, like Dante Alighieri’s “Divine Comedy,” of the supposed
abode of the dead. The narrative of Marbodius is one of the latest
works dealing with this theme, but it is not the least singular.
THE DESCENT OF MARBODIUS INTO HELL
In the fourteen hundred and fifty-third year of the incarnation of the
Son of God, a few days before the enemies of the Cross entered the city
of Helena and the great Constantine, it was given to me, Brother
Marbodius, an unworthy monk, to see and to hear what none had hitherto
seen or heard. I have composed a faithful narrative of those things so
that their memory may not perish with me, for man’s time is short.
On the first day of May in the aforesaid year, at the hour of vespers,
I was seated in the Abbey of Corrigan on a stone in the cloisters and,
as my custom was, I read the verses of the poet whom I love best of
all, Virgil, who has sung of the labours: of the field, of shepherds,
and of heroes. Evening was hanging its purple folds from the arches of
the cloisters and in a voice of emotion I was murmuring the verses
which describe how Dido, the Phœnician queen, wanders with her
ever-bleeding wound beneath the myrtles of hell. At that moment Brother
Hilary happened to pass by, followed by Brother Jacinth, the porter.
Brought up in the barbarous ages before the resurrection of the Muses,
Brother Hilary has not been initiated into the wisdom of the ancients;
nevertheless, the poetry of the Mantuan has, like a subtle torch, shed
some gleams of light into his understanding.
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · 영어권 · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『Penguin Island』
Anatole France
199,764자 (원문이 길어 앞부분만 · 전체 471,644자) · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1924년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.