Beyond question, it was theoretically best for the two opposing forces,
capital and labor, to fight their battle to its inevitable end without
interference, without truce, with quarter neither given nor taken on
either side. But practically--wasn't there something to be said for
such humane proposals of that of Jane Hastings? They would put off the
day of right conditions rightly and therefore permanently
founded--conditions in which master and slave or serf or wage-taker
would be no more; but, on the other hand, slaves with shorter hours of
toil and better surroundings could be enlightened more easily.
Perhaps. He was by no means sure; he could not but fear that anything
that tended to make the slave comfortable in his degradation must of
necessity weaken his aversion to degradation. Just as the worst kings
were the best kings because they hastened the fall of monarchy, so the
worst capitalists, the most rapacious, the most rigid enforcers of the
economic laws of a capitalistic society were the best capitalists, were
helping to hasten the day when men would work for what they earned and
would earn what they worked for--when every man's pay envelope would
contain his wages, his full wages, and nothing but his wages.
Still, where judgment was uncertain, he certainly had been unjust to
that well meaning girl. And was she really so worthless as he had on
first sight adjudged her? There might be exceptions to the rule that a
parasite born and bred can have no other instructor or idea but those
of parasitism. She was honest and earnest, was eager to learn the
truth. She might be put to some use. At any rate he had been unworthy
of his own ideals when he, assuming without question that she was the
usual capitalistic snob with the itch for gratifying vanity by
patronizing the "poor dear lower classes," had been almost insultingly
curt and mocking.
"What was the matter with me?" he asked himself. "I never acted in
that way before." And then he saw that his brusqueness had been the
cover for fear of of her--fear of the allure of her luxury and her
beauty. In love with her? He knew that he was not. No, his feeling
toward her was merely the crudest form of the tribute of man to
woman--though apparently woman as a rule preferred this form to any
other.
"I owe her an apology," he said to himself. And so it came to pass
that at three the following afternoon he was once more facing her in
that creeper-walled seclusion whose soft lights were almost equal to
light of gloaming or moon or stars in romantic charm.
Said he--always direct and simple, whether dealing with man or woman,
with devious person or straight:
"I've come to beg your pardon for what I said yesterday."
"You certainly were wild and strange," laughed she.
"I was supercilious," said he. "And worse than that there is not.
However, as I have apologized, and you have accepted my apology, we
need waste no more time about that. You wished to persuade your father
to----"
"Just a moment!" interrupted she. "I've a question to ask. WHY did you
treat me--why have you been treating me so--so harshly?"
"Because I was afraid of you," replied he. "I did not realize it, but
that was the reason."
"Afraid of ME," said she. "That's very flattering."
"No," said he, coloring. "In some mysterious way I had been betrayed
into thinking of you as no man ought to think of a woman unless he is
in love with her and she with him. I am ashamed of myself. But I
shall conquer that feeling--or keep away from you.... Do you understand
what the street car situation is?"
But she was not to be deflected from the main question, now that it had
been brought to the front so unexpectedly and in exactly the way most
favorable to her purposes. "You've made me uneasy," said she. "I
don't in the least understand what you mean. I have wanted, and I
still want, to be friends with you--good friends--just as you and Selma
Gordon are--though of course I couldn't hope to be as close a friend as
she is. I'm too ignorant--too useless."
He shook his head--with him, a gesture that conveyed the full strength
of negation. "We are on opposite sides of a line across which
friendship is impossible. I could not be your friend without being
false to myself. You couldn't be mine unless you were by some accident
flung into the working class and forced to adopt it as your own. Even
then you'd probably remain what you are. Only a small part of the
working class as yet is at heart of the working class. Most of us
secretly--almost openly--despise the life of work, and dream and hope a
time of fortune that will put us up among the masters and the idlers."
His expressive eyes became eloquent. "The false and shallow ideas that
have been educated into us for ages can't be uprooted in a few brief
years."
She felt the admiration she did not try to conceal. She saw the proud
and splendid conception of the dignity of labor--of labor as a
blessing, not a curse, as a badge of aristocracy and not of slavery and
shame. "You really believe that, don't you?" she said. "I know it's
true. I say I believe it--who doesn't SAY so? But I don't FEEL it."
"That's honest," said he heartily. "That's some thing to build on."
"And I'm going to build!" cried she. "You'll help me--won't you? I
know, it's a great deal to ask. Why should you take the time and the
trouble to bother with one single unimportant person."
"That's the way I spend my life--in adding one man or one woman to our
party--one at a time. It's slow building, but it's the only kind that
endures. There are twelve hundred of us now--twelve hundred voters, I
mean. Ten years ago there were only three hundred. We'd expand much
more rapidly if it weren't for the constant shifts of population. Our
men are forced to go elsewhere as the pressure of capitalism gets too
strong. And in place of them come raw emigrants, ignorant, full of
dreams of becoming capitalists and exploiters of their fellow men and
idlers. Ambition they call it. Ambition!" He laughed. "What a
vulgar, what a cruel notion of rising in the world! To cease to be
useful, to become a burden to others! ... Did you ever think how many
poor creatures have to toil longer hours, how many children have to go
to the factory instead of to school, in order that there may be two
hundred and seven automobiles privately kept in this town and
seventy-four chauffeurs doing nothing but wait upon their masters?
Money doesn't grow on bushes, you know. Every cent of it has to be
earned by somebody--and earned by MANUAL labor."
"I must think about that," she said--for the first time as much
interested in what he was saying as in the man himself. No small
triumph for Victor over the mind of a woman dominated, as was Jane
Hastings, by the sex instinct that determines the thoughts and actions
of practically the entire female sex.
"Yes--think about it," he urged. "You will never see it--or
anything--until you see it for yourself."
"That's the way your party is built--isn't it?" inquired she. "Of those
who see it for themselves."
"Only those," replied he. "We want no others."
"Not even their votes?" said she shrewdly.
"Not even their votes," he answered. "We've no desire to get the
offices until we get them to keep. And when we shall have conquered
the city, we'll move on to the conquest of the county--then of the
district--then of the state. Our kind of movement is building in every
city now, and in most of the towns and many of the villages. The old
parties are falling to pieces because they stand for the old politics
of the two factions of the upper class quarreling over which of them
should superintend the exploiting of the people. Very few of us
realize what is going on before our very eyes--that we're seeing the
death agonies of one form of civilization and the birth-throes of a
newer form."
"And what will it be?" asked the girl.
She had been waiting for some sign of the "crank," the impractical
dreamer. She was confident that this question would reveal the man she
had been warned against--that in answering it he would betray his true
self. But he disappointed and surprised her.
"How can I tell what it will be?" said he. "I'm not a prophet. All I
can say is I am sure it will be human, full of imperfections, full of
opportunities for improvements--and that I hope it will be better than
what we have now. Probably not much better, but a little--and that
little, however small it may be, will be a gain. Doesn't history show
a slow but steady advance of the idea that the world is for the people
who live in it, a slow retreat of the idea that the world and the
people and all its and their resources are for a favored few of some
kind of an upper class? Yes--I think it is reasonable to hope that out
of the throes will come a freer and a happier and a more intelligent
race."
Suddenly she burst out, apparently irrelevantly: "But I can't--I
really can't agree with you that everyone ought to do physical labor.
That would drag the world down--yes, I'm sure it would."
"I guess you haven't thought about that," said he. "Painters do
physical labor--and sculptors--and writers--and all the scientific
men--and the inventors--and--" He laughed at her--"Who doesn't do
physical labor that does anything really useful? Why, you yourself--at
tennis and riding and such things--do heavy physical labor. I've only
to look at your body to see that. But it's of a foolish kind--foolish
and narrowly selfish."
"I see I'd better not try to argue with you," said she.
"No--don't argue--with me or with anybody," rejoined he. "Sit down
quietly and think about life--about your life. Think how it is best to
live so that you may get the most out of life--the most substantial
happiness. Don't go on doing the silly customary things simply because
a silly customary world says they are amusing and worth while.
Think--and do--for yourself, Jane Hastings."
She nodded slowly and thoughtfully. "I'll try to," she said. She
looked at him with the expression of the mind aroused. It was an
expression that often rewarded him after a long straight talk with a
fellow being. She went on: "I probably shan't do what you'd approve.
You see, I've got to be myself--got to live to a certain extent the
kind of a life fate has made for me."
"You couldn't successfully live any other," said he.
"But, while it won't be at all what you'd regard as a model life--or
even perhaps useful--it'll be very different--very much better--than it
would have been, if I hadn't met you--Victor Dorn."
"Oh, I've done nothing," said he. "All I try to do is to encourage my
fellow beings to be themselves. So--live your own life--the life you
can live best--just as you wear the clothes that fit and become you....
And now--about the street car question. What do you want of me?"
"Tell me what to say to father."
He shook his head. "Can't do it," said he. "There's a good place for
you to make a beginning. Put on an old dress and go down town and get
acquainted with the family life of the street-car men. Talk to their
wives and their children. Look into the whole business yourself."
"But I'm not--not competent to judge," objected she.
"Well, make yourself competent," advised he.
"I might get Miss Gordon to go with me," suggested she.
"You'll learn more thoroughly if you go alone," declared he.
She hesitated--ventured with a winning smile: "You won't go with
me--just to get me started right?"
"No," said he. "You've got to learn for yourself--or not at all. If I
go with you, you'll get my point of view, and it will take you so much
the longer to get your own."
"Perhaps you'd prefer I didn't go."
"It's not a matter of much importance, one way or the other--except
perhaps to yourself," replied he.
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · 영어권 · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『갈등』
데이비드 그레이엄 필립스 · 원제 The Conflict
199,550자 (원문이 길어 앞부분만 · 전체 534,307자) · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1911년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.