The Odyssey
by Homer
DONE INTO ENGLISH PROSE
by
S. H. BUTCHER, M.A.
_Fellow and Protector of University College, Oxford_
_Late Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge_
AND
A. LANG, M.A.
_Late Fellow of Merton College, Oxford_
Contents
PREFACE.
PREFACE TO THE THIRD EDITION.
INTRODUCTION.
The Odyssey
BOOK I.
BOOK II.
BOOK III.
BOOK IV.
BOOK V.
BOOK VI.
BOOK VII.
BOOK VIII.
BOOK IX.
BOOK X.
BOOK XI.
BOOK XII.
BOOK XIII.
BOOK XIV.
BOOK XV.
BOOK XVI.
BOOK XVII.
BOOK XVIII.
BOOK XIX.
BOOK XX.
BOOK XXI.
BOOK XXII.
BOOK XXIII.
BOOK XXIV.
As one that for a weary space has lain
Lulled by the song of Circe and her wine
In gardens near the pale of Proserpine,
Where that Ææan isle forgets the main,
And only the low lutes of love complain,
And only shadows of wan lovers pine,
As such an one were glad to know the brine
Salt on his lips, and the large air again,
So gladly, from the songs of modern speech
Men turn, and see the stars, and feel the free
Shrill wind beyond the close of heavy flowers,
And through the music of the languid hours
They hear like Ocean on a western beach
The surge and thunder of the Odyssey.
A. L.
PREFACE.
There would have been less controversy about the proper method of
Homeric translation, if critics had recognised that the question is a
purely relative one, that of Homer there can be no final translation.
The taste and the literary habits of each age demand different
qualities in poetry, and therefore a different sort of rendering of
Homer. To the men of the time of Elizabeth, Homer would have appeared
bald, it seems, and lacking in ingenuity, if he had been presented in
his antique simplicity. For the Elizabethan age, Chapman supplied what
was then necessary, and the mannerisms that were then deemed of the
essence of poetry, namely, daring and luxurious conceits. Thus in
Chapman’s verse Troy must “shed her towers for tears of overthrow,” and
when the winds toss Odysseus about, their sport must be called “the
horrid tennis.”
In the age of Anne, “dignity” and “correctness” had to be given to
Homer, and Pope gave them by aid of his dazzling rhetoric, his
antitheses, his _netteté_, his command of every conventional and
favourite artifice. Without Chapman’s conceits, Homer’s poems would
hardly have been what the Elizabethans took for poetry; without Pope’s
smoothness, and Pope’s points, the Iliad and Odyssey would have seemed
rude, and harsh in the age of Anne. These great translations must
always live as English poems. As transcripts of Homer they are like
pictures drawn from a lost point of view. _Chaque siècle depuis le xvie
a eu de ce côté son belvéder différent_. Again, when Europe woke to a
sense, an almost exaggerated and certainly uncritical sense, of the
value of her songs of the people, of all the ballads that Herder,
Scott, Lonnrot, and the rest collected, it was commonly said that Homer
was a ballad-minstrel, that the translator must imitate the simplicity,
and even adopt the formulae of the ballad. Hence came the renderings of
Maginn, the experiments of Mr. Gladstone, and others. There was some
excuse for the error of critics who asked for a Homer in ballad rhyme.
The Epic poet, the poet of gods and heroes, did indeed inherit some of
the formulae of the earlier _Volks-lied_. Homer, like the author of
_The Song of Roland_, like the singers of the _Kalevala_, uses
constantly recurring epithets, and repeats, word for word, certain
emphatic passages, messages, and so on. That custom is essential in the
ballad, it is an accident not the essence of the epic. The epic is a
poem of complete and elaborate art, but it still bears some birthmarks,
some signs of the early popular chant, out of which it sprung, as the
garden-rose springs from the wild stock, When this is recognised the
demand for ballad-like simplicity and “ballad-slang” ceases to exist,
and then all Homeric translations in the ballad manner cease to
represent our conception of Homer. After the belief in the ballad
manner follows the recognition of the romantic vein in Homer, and, as a
result, came Mr. Worsley’s admirable Odyssey. This masterly translation
does all that can be done for the Odyssey in the romantic style. The
smoothness of the verse, the wonderful closeness to the original,
reproduce all of Homer, in music and in meaning, that can be rendered
in English verse. There still, however, seems an aspect Homeric poems,
and a demand in connection with Homer to be recognised, and to be
satisfied.
Sainte-Beuve says, with reference probably to M. Leconte de Lisle’s
prose version of the epics, that some people treat the epics too much
as if they were sagas. Now the Homeric epics are sagas, but then they
are the sagas of the divine heroic age of Greece, and thus are told
with an art which is not the art of the Northern poets. The epics are
stories about the adventures of men living in most respects like the
men of our own race who dwelt in Iceland, Norway, Denmark, and Sweden.
The epics are, in a way, and as far as manners and institutions are
concerned, historical documents. Whoever regards them in this way, must
wish to read them exactly as they have reached us, without modern
ornament, with nothing added or omitted. He must recognise, with Mr.
Matthew Arnold, that what he now wants, namely, the simple truth about
the matter of the poem, can only be given in prose, “for in a verse
translation no original work is any longer recognisable.” It is for
this reason that we have attempted to tell once more, in simple prose,
the story of Odysseus. We have tried to transfer, not all the truth
about the poem, but the historical truth, into English. In this process
Homer must lose at least half his charm, his bright and equable speed,
the musical current of that narrative, which, like the river of Egypt,
flows from an indiscoverable source, and mirrors the temples and the
palaces of unforgotten gods and kings. Without this music of verse,
only a half truth about Homer can be told, but then it is that half of
the truth which, at this moment, it seems most necessary to tell. This
is the half of the truth that the translators who use verse cannot
easily tell. They _must_ be adding to Homer, talking with Pope about
“tracing the mazy lev’ret o’er the lawn,” or with Mr. Worsley about the
islands that are “stars of the blue Aegaean,” or with Dr. Hawtrey about
“the earth’s soft arms,” when Homer says nothing at all about the “mazy
lev’ret,” or the “stars of the blue Aegaean,” or the “soft arms” of
earth. It would be impertinent indeed to blame any of these
translations in their place. They give that which the romantic reader
of poetry, or the student of the age of Anne, looks for in verse; and
without tags of this sort, a translation of Homer in verse cannot well
be made to hold together.
There can be then, it appears, no final English translation of Homer.
In each there must be, in addition to what is Greek and eternal, the
element of what is modern, personal, and fleeting. Thus we trust that
there may be room for “the pale and far-off shadow of a prose
translation,” of which the aim is limited and humble. A prose
translation cannot give the movement and the fire of a successful
translation in verse; it only gathers, as it were, the crumbs which
fall from the richer table, only tells the story, without the song. Yet
to a prose translation is permitted, perhaps, that close adherence to
the archaisms of the epic, which in verse become mere oddities. The
double epithets, the recurring epithets of Homer, if rendered into
verse, delay and puzzle the reader, as the Greek does not delay or
puzzle him. In prose he may endure them, or even care to study them as
the survivals of a stage of taste, which is to be found in its prime in
the sagas. These double and recurring epithets of Homer are a softer
form of the quaint Northern periphrases, which make the sea the “swan’s
bath,” gold, the “dragon’s hoard,” men, the “ring-givers,” and so on.
We do not know whether it is necessary to defend our choice of a
somewhat antiquated prose. Homer has no ideas which cannot be expressed
in words that are “old and plain,” and to words that are old and plain,
and, as a rule, to such terms as, being used by the Translators of the
Bible, are still not unfamiliar, we have tried to restrict ourselves.
It may be objected, that the employment of language which does not come
spontaneously to the lips, is an affectation out of place in a version
of the Odyssey. To this we may answer that the Greek Epic dialect, like
the English of our Bible, was a thing of slow growth and composite
nature, that it was never a spoken language, nor, except for certain
poetical purposes, a written language. Thus the Biblical English seems
as nearly analogous to the Epic Greek, as anything that our tongue has
to offer.
The few foot-notes in this book are chiefly intended to make clear some
passages where there is a choice of reading. The notes at the end,
which we would like to have written in the form of essays, and in
company with more complete philological and archaeological studies, are
chiefly meant to elucidate the life of Homer’s men.
We have received much help from many friends, and especially from Mr.
R. W. Raper, Fellow of Trinity College, Oxford and Mr. Gerald Balfour,
Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, who have aided us with many
suggestions while the book was passing through the press.
In the interpretation of B. i. 411, ii. 191, v. 90, and 471, we have
departed from the received view, and followed Mr. Raper, who, however,
has not been able to read through the proof-sheets further than Book
xii.
We have adopted La Roche’s text (Homeri Odyssea, J. La Roche, Leipzig,
1867), except in a few cases where we mention our reading in a
foot-note.
The Arguments prefixed to the Books are taken, with very slight
alterations, from Hobbes’ Translation of the Odyssey.
It is hoped that the Introduction added to the second edition may
illustrate the growth of those national legends on which Homer worked,
and may elucidate the plot of the Odyssey.
PREFACE TO THE THIRD EDITION.
We owe our thanks to the Rev. E. Warre, of Eton College, for certain
corrections on nautical points. In particular, he has convinced us that
the raft of Odysseus in B. v. is a raft strictly so called, and that it
is not, under the poet’s description, elaborated into a ship, as has
been commonly supposed. The translation of the passage (B. v. 246-261)
is accordingly altered.
INTRODUCTION.
COMPOSITION AND PLOT OF THE ODYSSEY.
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · 영어권 · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『오디세이아』
호메로스 · 원제 The Odyssey of Homer · 번역 S. H. (Samuel Henry) Butcher, Andrew Lang
199,992자 (원문이 길어 앞부분만 · 전체 753,308자) · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1912년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.