In the central lowest space, a dark and whiskered man enters a dark
chamber; his left hand is on the lock of the door; in his right he holds
up a lantern. The light of the lantern reveals a young man in a soft hat
of Tyrolese shape. His features are purely classical, his nose is
Grecian, his locks are long (at least, according to the taste of to-day);
he wears a light paletot, buttoned to the throat; his right arm hangs by
his side; his left hand is thrust into the breast of his coat. He calmly
regards the dark man with the lantern. That man, of course, is Jasper.
The young man is EDWIN DROOD, of the Grecian nose, hyacinthine locks, and
classic features, as in Sir L. Fildes’s third illustration.
Mr. Proctor correctly understood the unmistakable meaning of this last
design, Jasper entering the vault—
“_To-day the dead are living_,
_The lost is found to-day_.”
Mr. Cuming Walters tells us that he did not examine these designs by Mr.
Collins till he had formed his theory, and finished his book. “On the
conclusion of the whole work the pictures were referred to for the first
time, and were then found to support in the most striking manner the
opinions arrived at,” namely, that Drood was killed, and that Helena is
Datchery. Thus does theory blind us to facts!
Mr. Cuming Walters connects the figure of the whiskerless young man
kneeling to a girl in a garden seat, with the whiskered Jasper’s proposal
to Rosa in a garden seat. But Jasper does not kneel to Rosa; he stands
apart, leaning on a sundial; he only once vaguely “touches” her, which
she resents; he does not kneel; he does not kiss her hand (Rosa “took the
kiss sedately,” like Maud in the poem); and—Jasper had lustrous thick
black whiskers.
Again, the same whiskerless young man, bounding up the spiral staircase
in daylight, and wildly pointing upwards, is taken by Mr. Cuming Walters
to represent Jasper climbing the staircase to reconnoitre, at night, with
a lantern, and, of course, with black whiskers. The two well-dressed men
on the stairs (Grewgious, or Tartar, and Crisparkle) also, according to
Mr. Cuming Walters, “relate to Jasper’s unaccountable expedition with
Durdles to the Cathedral.” Neither of them is Jasper; neither of them is
Durdles, “in a suit of coarse flannel”—a disreputable jacket, as Sir L.
Fildes depicts him—“with horn buttons,” and a battered old tall hat.
These interpretations are quite demonstrably erroneous and even
impossible. Mr. Archer interprets the designs exactly as I do.
As to the young man in the light of Jasper’s lamp, Mr. Cuming Walters
says, “the large hat and the tightly-buttoned surtout must be observed;
they are the articles of clothing on which most stress is laid in the
description of Datchery. But the face is young.” The face of Datchery
was elderly, and he had a huge shock of white hair, a wig. Datchery wore
“a tightish blue surtout, with a buff waistcoat and grey trousers; he had
something of a military air.” The young man in the vault has anything
but a military air; he shows no waistcoat, and he does not wear “a
tightish blue surtout,” or any surtout at all.
[Picture: Under the trees]
The surtout of the period is shown, worn by Jasper, in Sir L. Fildes’s
sixth and ninth illustrations. It is a frock-coat; the collar descends
far below the top of the waistcoat (buff or otherwise), displaying that
garment; the coat is tightly buttoned beneath, revealing the figure; the
tails of the coat do not reach the knees of the wearer. The young man in
the vault, on the other hand, wears a loose paletot, buttoned to the
throat (vaults are chilly places), and the coat falls so as to cover the
knees; at least, partially. The young man is not, like Helena, “very
dark, and fierce of look, . . . of almost the gipsy type.” He is blonde,
sedate, and of the classic type, as Drood was. He is no more like Helena
than Crisparkle is like Durdles. Mr. Cuming Walters says that Mr.
Proctor was “unable to allude to the prophetic picture by Collins.” As a
fact, this picture is fully described by Mr. Proctor, but Mr. Walters
used the wrong edition of his book, unwittingly.
Mr. Proctor writes:—“Creeping down the crypt steps, oppressed by growing
horror and by terror of coming judgment, sickening under fears engendered
by the darkness of night and the charnel-house air he breathed, Jasper
opens the door of the tomb and holds up his lantern, shuddering at the
thought of what it may reveal to him.
“And what sees he? Is it the spirit of his victim that stands there, ‘in
his habit as he lived,’ his hand clasped on his breast, where the ring
had been when he was murdered? What else can Jasper deem it? There,
clearly visible in the gloom at the back of the tomb, stands Edwin Drood,
with stern look fixed on him—pale, silent, relentless!”
[Picture: Durdles Cautions Mr. Sapsea against Boasting]
Again, “On the title-page are given two of the small pictures from the
Love side of the cover, two from the Murder side, and the central picture
below, which presents the central horror of the story—the end and aim of
the ‘Datchery assumption’ and of Mr. Grewgious’s plans—showing Jasper
driven to seek for the proofs of his crime amid the dust to which, as he
thought, the flesh and bones, and the very clothes of his victim, had
been reduced.”
There are only two possible choices; either Collins, under Dickens’s oral
instructions, depicted Jasper finding Drood alive in the vault, an
incident which was to occur in the story; or Dickens bade Collins do this
for the purpose of misleading his readers in an illegitimate manner;
while the young man in the vault was really to be some person “made up”
to look like Drood, and so to frighten Jasper with a pseudo-ghost of that
hero. The latter device, the misleading picture, would be childish, and
the pseudo-ghost, exactly like Drood, could not be acted by the
gipsy-like, fierce Helena, or by any other person in the romance.
MR. WALTERS’S THEORY CONTINUED
Mr. Cuming Walters guesses that Jasper was to aim a deadly blow (with his
left hand, to judge from the picture) at Helena, and that Neville “was to
give his life for hers.” But, manifestly, Neville was to lead the hunt
of Jasper up the spiral stair, as in Collins’s design, and was to be
dashed from the roof: his body beneath was to be “_that_, I never saw
before. _That_ must be real. Look what a poor mean miserable thing it
is!” as Jasper says in his vision.
Mr. Cuming Walters, pursuing his idea of Helena as both Datchery and also
as the owner of “the _young_ face” of the youth in the vault (and also of
the young hands, a young girl’s hands could never pass for those of “an
elderly buffer”), exclaims: “Imagine the intense power of the dramatic
climax, when Datchery, the elderly man, is re-transformed into Helena
Landless, the young and handsome woman; and when she reveals the
seemingly impenetrable secret which had been closed up in one guilty
man’s mind.”
The situations are startling, I admit, but how would Canon Crisparkle
like them? He is, we know, to marry Helena, “the young person, my dear,”
Miss Twinkleton would say, “who for months lived alone, at inns, wearing
a blue surtout, a buff waistcoat, and grey—” Here horror chokes the
utterance of Miss Twinkleton. “Then she was in the vault in _another_
disguise, not more womanly, at that awful scene when poor Mr. Jasper was
driven mad, so that he confessed all sorts of nonsense, for, my dear, all
the Close believes that it _was_ nonsense, and that Mr. Jasper was
reduced to insanity by persecution. And Mr. Crisparkle, with that
elegant dainty mother of his—it has broken her heart—is marrying this
half-caste gipsy _trollop_, with her blue surtout and grey—oh, it is a
disgrace to Cloisterham!”
The climax, in fact, as devised by Mr. Cuming Walters, is rather too
dramatic for the comfort of a minor canon. A humorist like Dickens ought
to have seen the absurdity of the situation. Mr. Walters _may_ be right,
Helena may be Datchery, but she ought not to be.
WHO WAS THE PRINCESS PUFFER?
Who was the opium hag, the Princess Puffer? Mr. Cuming Walters writes:
“We make a guess, for Dickens gives us no solid facts. But when we
remember that not a word is said throughout the volume of Jasper’s
antecedents, who he was, and where he came from; when we remember that
but for his nephew he was a lonely man; when we see that he was both
criminal and artist; when we observe his own wheedling propensity, his
false and fulsome protestations of affection, his slyness, his subtlety,
his heartlessness, his tenacity; and when, above all, we know that the
opium vice is _hereditary_, and that a _young_ man would not be addicted
to it unless born with the craving; {91} then, it is not too wild a
conjecture that Jasper was the wayward progeny of this same opium-eating
woman, all of whose characteristics he possessed, and, perchance, of a
man of criminal instincts, but of a superior position. Jasper is a
morbid and diseased being while still in the twenties, a mixture of
genius and vice. He hates and he loves fiercely, as if there were wild
gipsy blood in his veins. Though seemingly a model of decorum and
devoted to his art, he complains of his “daily drudging round” and “the
cramped monotony of his existence.” He commits his crime with the
ruthlessness of a beast, his own nature being wholly untamed. If we
deduce that his father was an adventurer and a vagabond, we shall not be
far wrong. If we deduce that his mother was the opium-eater, prematurely
aged, who had transmitted her vicious propensity to her child, we shall
almost certainly be right.”
WHO WAS JASPER?
Who was Jasper? He was the brother-in-law of the late Mr. Drood, a
respected engineer, and University man. We do not know whence came Mrs.
Drood, Jasper’s sister, but is it likely that her mother “drank
heaven’s-hard”—so the hag says of herself—then took to keeping an opium
den, and there entertained her son Jasper, already an accomplished
vocalist, but in a lower station than that to which his musical genius
later raised him, as lay Precentor? If the Princess Puffer be, as on Mr.
Cuming Walters’s theory she is, Edwin’s long-lost grandmother, her
discovery would be unwelcome to Edwin. Probably she did not live much
longer; “my lungs are like cabbage nets,” she says. Mr. Cuming Walters
goes on—
“Her purpose is left obscure. How easily, however, we see possibilities
in a direction such as this. The father, perhaps a proud, handsome man,
deserts the woman, and removes the child. The woman hates both for
scorning her, but the father dies, or disappears, and is beyond her
vengeance. Then the child, victim to the ills in his blood, creeps back
to the opium den, not knowing his mother, but immediately recognized by
her. She will make the child suffer for the sins of the father, who had
destroyed her happiness. Such a theme was one which appealed to Dickens.
It must not, however, be urged; and the crucial question after all is
concerned with the opium woman as one of the unconscious instruments of
justice, aiding with her trifle of circumstantial evidence the Nemesis
awaiting Jasper.
“Another hypothesis—following on the Carker theme in ‘Dombey and Son’—is
that Jasper, a dissolute and degenerate man, lascivious, and heartless,
may have wronged a child of the woman’s; but it is not likely that
Dickens would repeat the Mrs. Brown story.”
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · 영어권 · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『The Puzzle of Dickens's Last Plot』
Andrew Lang
86,380자 · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1912년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.