Next came: ‘Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, to which is added, an Essay on his
Language and Versification; an introductory discourse; notes, and a
glossary. By Thomas Tyrwhitt, London, 1775-8, 8vo, 5 vols.’ A work of high
literary value, to which I am greatly indebted for many necessary notes.
Reprinted in 1798 in 4to, 2 vols., by the University of Oxford; and again,
at London, in 1822, in post 8vo, 5 vols.; (by Pickering) in 1830, 8vo, 5
vols.; [xvi] and (by Moxon) in 1845, in 1 vol. imp. 8vo. The last of these
adds poor texts of the rest of Chaucer’s Works, from old black-letter
editions, with which Tyrwhitt had nothing to do. In Tyrwhitt’s text, the
number of grammatical errors is very large, and he frequently introduces
words into the text without authority. For some account of the later
editions of Chaucer’s Works, see the Introduction to the Legend of Good
Women, in vol. iii. I may note, by the way, that the editions by Wright,
Bell, and Morris are all founded on MS. Harl. 7334, a very unsafe MS. in
some respects; see p. viii (above).
It is necessary to add here a few words of warning. Wright’s edition,
though it has many merits, turns out, in practice, to be dangerously
untrustworthy. He frequently inserts words, borrowed from Tyrwhitt’s
edition (which he heartily condemns as being full of errors in
grammar), without the least indication that they are _not in the MS._
This becomes the more serious when we find, upon examination, that
Tyrwhitt had likewise no authority for some of such insertions, but
simply introduced them, by guess, to fill up a line in a way that
pleased him. For example, A 628 runs thus, in all the seven MSS.:—
‘Of his visage children were aferd.’ It is quite correct; for ‘viság-e’
is trisyllabic. Tyrwhitt did not know this, and counted the syllables
as _two_ only, neglecting the final _e_. The line seemed then too short;
so he inserted _sore_ before _aferd_, thus ruining the scansion. Wright
follows suit, and inserts _sore_, though it is not in his MS.; giving
no notice at all of what he has done. Bell follows suit, and the word
is even preserved in Morris; but the latter prints the word in italics,
to shew that it is not in the MS. Nor is it in the Six-text.
I shall not adduce more instances, but shall content myself with saying
that, until the publications of the Chaucer Society appeared, no reader
had the means of knowing what the best MS. texts were really like. All
who have been accustomed to former (complete) editions have necessarily
imbibed hundreds of false impressions, and have necessarily accepted
numberless theories as to the scansion of lines which they will, in
course of due time, be prepared to abandon. In the course of my work,
it has been made clear to me that Chaucer’s text has been manipulated
and sophisticated, frequently in most cunning and plausible ways, to a
far greater extent than I could have believed to be possible. This is
not a pleasant subject, and I only mention it for the use of scholars.
Such variations fortunately seldom affect the sense; but they vitiate
the scansion, the grammar, and the etymology in many cases. Of course
it will be understood that I am saying no more than I can fully
substantiate.
It is absolutely appalling to read such a statement as the following in
Bell’s edition, vol. i. p. 60. ‘All deviations, either from Mr.
Wright’s edition, or from the original MS., are pointed out in the
footnotes for the ultimate satisfaction of the reader.’ For the
instances in which this is really done are very rare indeed, in spite
of the large number of such deviations.
Of Tyrwhitt’s text, it is sufficient to remark that it was hardly
possible, at [xvii] that date, for a better text to have been produced.
The rules of Middle English grammar had not been formulated, so that we
are not surprised to find that he constantly makes the past tense of a
weak verb monosyllabic, when it should be dissyllabic, and treats the
past participle as dissyllabic, when it should be monosyllabic: which
makes wild work with the scansion. It is also to be regretted that he
based his text upon the faulty black-letter editions, though he took a
great deal of pains in collating them with various MSS.
On the other hand, his literary notes are full of learning and
research; and the number of admirable illustrations by which he has
efficiently elucidated the text is very great. His reputation as one of
the foremost of our literary critics is thoroughly established, and
needs no comment.
Mr. Wright’s notes are likewise excellent, and resulted from a wide
reading. I have also found some most useful hints in the notes to
Bell’s edition. Of all such sources of information I have been only too
glad to avail myself, as is more fully shewn in the succeeding volume.
§ 4. PLAN OF THE PRESENT EDITION.
The text of the present edition of the Canterbury Tales is founded upon
that of the Ellesmere MS. (E.) It has been collated throughout with that of
the other six MSS. published by the Chaucer Society. Of these seven MSS.,
the Harleian MS. 7334 (Hl.) was printed separately. The other six were
printed in the valuable ‘Six-text’ edition, to which I constantly have
occasion to refer, in parallel columns. The six MSS. are: E. (Ellesmere),
Hn. (Hengwrt), Cm. (Cambridge, Gg. 4. 27), Cp. (Corpus Coll., Oxford), Pt.
(Petworth), and Ln. (Lansdowne). MSS. E. Hn. Cm. represent the earliest
type (A) of the text; Hl., a transitional type (B); Cp. and Ln., a still
later type (C); and Pt., the latest of all (D), but hardly differing from
C.
In using these terms, ‘earliest,’ &c., I do not refer to the age of the
MSS., but to the type of text which they exhibit.
In the list of MSS. given above, Hl. is no. 1; E., Hn., Cm., are nos. 40,
41, and 28; and Cp., Pt., Ln., are nos. 24, 42, and 10 respectively.
Of all the MSS., E. is the best in nearly every respect. It not only gives
good lines and good sense, but is also (usually) grammatically accurate and
thoroughly well spelt. The publication of it has been a very great boon to
all Chaucer students, for which Dr. Furnivall will be ever gratefully
remembered. We must not omit, at the same time, to recognise the liberality
and generosity of the owner of the MS., who so freely permitted such full
use of it to be made; the same remark applies, equally, to the [xviii]
owners of the Hengwrt and the Petworth MSS. The names of the Earl of
Ellesmere, Mr. Wm. W. E. Wynne of Peniarth, and Lord Leconfield have
deservedly become as ‘familiar as household words’ to many a student of
Chaucer.
This splendid MS. has also the great merit of being complete, requiring no
supplement from any other source, except in the few cases where a line or
two has been missed. For example, it does not contain A 252 _b-c_ (found in
Hn. only); nor A 2681-2 (also not in Hn. or Cm.); nor B 1163-1190 (also not
in Hn. or Cm.); nor B 1995 (very rare indeed).
It is slightly imperfect in B 2510, 2514, 2525, 2526, 2623-4, 2746, 2967.
It drops B 3147-8, C 103-4, C 297-8 (not in Hn. Cm. Pt.), E 1358-61, G
564-5; and has a few defects in the Parson’s Tale in I 190, 273, &c. In the
Tale of Melibeus, the French original shews that _all_ the MSS. have lost B
2252-3, 2623-4, which have to be supplied by translation.
None of the seven MSS. have B 4637-4652; these lines are genuine, but were
probably meant to be cancelled. They only occur, to my knowledge, in four
MSS., nos. 7, 11, 25, and 29; though found also in the old black-letter
editions.
On the other hand, E. preserves lines rarely found elsewhere. Such are A
3155-6, 3721-2, F 1455-6, 1493-9; twelve genuine lines, none of which are
in Tyrwhitt, and only the first two are in Wright. Observe also the stanza
in the footnote to p. 424; with which compare B 3083, on p. 241.
The text of the Ellesmere MS. has only been corrected in cases where
careful collation suggests a desirable improvement. Every instance of this
character is invariably recorded in the footnotes. Thus, in A 8, the
grammar and scansion require _half-e_, not _half_; though, curiously
enough, this correct form appears in Hl. only, among all the seven MSS. In
very difficult cases, other MSS. (besides the seven) have been collated,
but I have seldom gained much by it. The chief additional MSS. thus used
are Dd.= Cambridge, Dd. 4. 24 (no. 29 above); Slo. or Sl. = Sloane 1685
(no. 8); Roy. or Rl. = Royal 18 C 2 (no. 6); Harl. = Harleian 1758 (see p.
645); Li. or Lich. = Lichfield MS. (no. 35), for the Canon’s Yeoman’s Tale;
and others that are sufficiently indicated.
I have paid especial attention to the suffixes required by Middle-English
grammar, to the scansion, and to the pronunciation; and I suppose that this
is the first complete edition in which the [xix] spelling has been tested
by phonetic considerations. With a view to making the spelling a little
clearer and more consistent, I have ventured to adopt certain methods which
I here explain.
In certain words of variable spelling in E., such as _whan_ or _whanne,
than_ or _thanne_, I have adopted that form which the scansion requires;
but the MS. is usually right.
E. usually has _hise_ for _his_ with a plural sb., as in l. 1; I use _his_
always, except in prose. E. has _hir, here_, for her, their; I use _hir_
only, except at the end of a line.
E. uses the endings _-ight_ or _-yght_, _-inde_ or _-ynde_; I use _-ight_
_-inde_ only; and, in general, I use _i_ to represent short _i_, and _y_ to
represent long _i_, as in _king, wyf_. Such is the usual habit of the
scribe, but he often changes _i_ into _y_ before _m_ and _n_, to make his
writing clearer; such a precaution is needless in modern printing. Thus, in
l. 42, I replace the scribe’s _bigynne_ by _biginne_; and in l. 78, I
replace his _pilgrymage_ by _pilgrimage_. This makes the text easier to
read.
For a like reason, where equivalent spellings occur, I select the simpler;
writing _couthe_ (as in Pt.) for _kowthe_, _sote_ for _soote_, _sege_ for
_seege_, and so on. In words such as _our_ or _oure_, _your_ or _youre_,
_hir_ or _hire_, _neuer_ or _neuere_, I usually give the simpler forms,
without the final _-e_, when the _-e_ is obviously silent.
For consonantal _u_, as in _neuer_, I write _v_, as in _never_. This is
usual in all editions. But I could not bring myself to use _j_ for _i_
consonant; the anachronism is too great. _Never_ for _neuer_ is common in
the fifteenth century, but _j_ does not occur even in the first folio of
Shakespeare. I therefore usually keep the capital _i_ of the MSS. and of
the Elizabethan printers, as in _Ioye_ (=_joye_) where initial, and the
small _i_, as in _enioinen_=_enjoinen_) elsewhere. Those who dislike such
conservatism may be comforted by the reflection that the sound rarely
occurs.
The word _eye_ has to be altered to _yë_ at the end of a line, to preserve
the rimes. The scribes usually write _eye_ in the middle of a line, but
when they come to it at the end of one, they are fairly puzzled. In l. 10,
the scribe of Hn. writes _Iye_, and that of Ln. writes _yhe_; and the
variations on this theme are most curious. The spelling _ye_ (=_yë_) is,
however, common; as in A 1096 (Cm., Pt.). I print it ‘yë’ to distinguish it
from _ye_, the pl. pronoun.
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · enm · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『Chaucer's Works, Volume 4 — The Canterbury Tales』
Geoffrey Chaucer
199,793자 (원문이 길어 앞부분만 · 전체 1,442,350자) · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1400년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.