There are no new ideas in plots. “All the stories have been told,” and
all the merit lies in the manner of the telling. Dickens had used the
unsuspected watcher, as Mr. Proctor shows, in almost all his novels. In
_Martin Chuzzlewit_, when Jonas finds that Nadgett has been the watcher,
Dickens writes, “The dead man might have come out of his grave and not
confounded and appalled him so.” Now, to Jasper, Edwin _was_ “the dead
man,” and Edwin’s grave contained quicklime. Jasper was sure that he had
done for Edwin: he had taken Edwin’s watch, chain, and scarf-pin; he
believed that he had left him, drugged, in quicklime, in a locked vault.
Consequently the reappearance of Edwin, quite well, in the vault where
Jasper had buried him, would be a very new idea to Jasper; would
“confound and appall him.” Jasper would have emotions, at that
spectacle, and so would the reader! It is not every day, even in our age
of sixpenny novels, that a murderer is compelled to visit, alone, at
night, the vault which holds his victim’s “cold remains,” and therein
finds the victim “come up, smiling.”
Yes, for business purposes, this idea was new enough! The idea was
“difficult to work,” says Dickens, with obvious truth. How was he to get
the quicklime into the vault, and Drood, alive, out of the vault? As to
the reader, he would at first take Datchery for Drood, and then think,
“No, that is impossible, and also is stale. Datchery cannot be Drood,”
and thus the reader would remain in a pleasant state of puzzledom, as he
does, unto this day.
If Edwin is dead, there is not much “Mystery” about him. We have as good
as seen Jasper strangle him and take his pin, chain, and watch. Yet by
adroitly managing the conduct of Mr. Grewgious, Dickens persuaded Mr.
Proctor that certainly, Grewgious knew Edwin to be alive. As Grewgious
knew, from Helena, all that was necessary to provoke his experiment on
Jasper’s nerves, Mr. Proctor argued on false premises, but that was due
to the craft of Dickens. Mr. Proctor rejected Forster’s report, from
memory, of what he understood to be the “incommunicable secret” of
Dickens’s plot, and I think that he was justified in the rejection.
Forster does not seem to have cared about the thing—he refers lightly to
“the reader curious in such matters”—when once he had received his
explanation from Dickens. His memory, in the space of five years, may
have been inaccurate: he probably neither knew nor cared who Datchery
was; and he may readily have misunderstood what Dickens told him, orally,
about the ring, as the instrument of detection. Moreover, Forster quite
overlooked one source of evidence, as I shall show later.
MR. PROCTOR’S THEORY
Mr. Proctor’s theory of the story is that Jasper, after Edwin’s return at
midnight on Christmas Eve, recommended a warm drink—mulled wine,
drugged—and then proposed another stroll of inspection of the effects of
the storm. He then strangled him, somewhere, and placed him in the
quicklime in the Sapsea vault, locked him in, and went to bed. Next,
according to Mr. Proctor, Durdles, then, “lying drunk in the precincts,”
for some reason taps with his hammer on the wall of the Sapsea vault,
detects the presence of a foreign body, opens the tomb, and finds Drood
in the quicklime, “his face fortunately protected by the strong silk
shawl with which Jasper has intended to throttle him.”
A MISTAKEN THEORY
This is “thin,” very “thin!” Dickens must have had some better scheme
than Mr. Proctor’s. Why did Jasper not “mak sikker” like Kirkpatrick
with the Red Comyn? Why did he leave his silk scarf? It might come to
be asked for; to be sure the quicklime would destroy it, but why did
Jasper leave it? Why did the intoxicated Durdles come out of the crypt,
if he was there, enter the graveyard, and begin tapping at the wall of
the vault? Why not open the door? he had the key.
Suppose, however, all this to have occurred, and suppose, with Mr.
Proctor, that Durdles and Deputy carried Edwin to the Tramps’ lodgings,
would Durdles fail to recognize Edwin? We are to guess that Grewgious
was present, or disturbed at his inn, or somehow brought into touch with
Edwin, and bribed Durdles to silence, “until a scheme for the punishment
of Jasper had been devised.”
All this set of conjectures is crude to the last degree. We do not know
how Dickens meant to get Edwin into and out of the vault. Granting that
Edwin was drugged, Jasper might lead Edwin in, considering the licence
extended to the effects of drugs in novels, and might strangle him there.
Above all, how did Grewgious, if in Cloisterham, come to be at hand at
midnight?
ANOTHER WAY
If I must make a guess, I conjecture that Jasper had one of his “filmy”
seizures, was “in a frightful sort of dream,” and bungled the murder:
made an incomplete job of it. Half-strangled men and women have often
recovered. In Jasper’s opium vision and reminiscence there was no
resistance, all was very soon over. Jasper might even bungle the locking
of the door of the vault. He was apt to have a seizure after opium, in
moments of excitement, and _he had been at the opium den through the
night of December_ 23, for the hag tracked him from her house in town to
Cloisterham on December 24, the day of the crime. Grant that his
accustomed fit came upon him during the excitement of the murder, as it
does come after “a nicht wi’ opium,” in chapter ii., when Edwin excites
him by contemptuous talk of the girl whom Jasper loves so furiously—and
then anything may happen!
Jasper murders Edwin inefficiently; he has a fit; while he is unconscious
the quicklime revives Edwin, by burning his hand, say, and, during
Jasper’s swoon, Edwin, like another famous prisoner, “has a happy
thought, he opens the door, and walks out.”
Being drugged, he is in a dreamy state; knows not clearly what has
occurred, or who attacked him. Jasper revives, “look on’t again he dare
not,”—on the body of his victim—and _he_ walks out and goes home, where
his red lamp has burned all the time—“thinking it all wery capital.”
“Another way,”—Jasper not only fails to strangle Drood, but fails to lock
the door of the vault, and Drood walks out after Jasper has gone. Jasper
has, before his fit, “removed from the body the most lasting, the best
known, and most easily recognizable things upon it, the watch and
scarf-pin.” So Dickens puts the popular view of the case against Neville
Landless, and so we are to presume that Jasper acted. If he removed no
more things from the body than these, he made a fatal oversight.
Meanwhile, how does Edwin, once out of the vault, make good a secret
escape from Cloisterham? Mr. Proctor invokes the aid of Mr. Grewgious,
but does not explain why Grewgious was on the spot. I venture to think
it not inconceivable that Mr. Grewgious having come down to Cloisterham
by a late train, on Christmas Eve, to keep his Christmas appointment with
Rosa, paid a darkling visit to the tomb of his lost love, Rosa’s mother.
Grewgious was very sentimental, but too secretive to pay such a visit by
daylight. “A night of memories and sighs” he might “consecrate” to his
lost lady love, as Landor did to Rose Aylmer. Grewgious was to have
helped Bazzard to eat a turkey on Christmas Day. But he could get out of
that engagement. He would wish to see Edwin and Rosa together, and Edwin
was leaving Cloisterham. The date of Grewgious’s arrival at Cloisterham
is studiously concealed. I offer at least a conceivable motive for
Grewgious’s possible presence at the churchyard. Mrs. Bud, his lost
love, we have been told, was buried hard by the Sapsea monument. If
Grewgious visited her tomb, he was on the spot to help Edwin, supposing
Edwin to escape. Unlikelier things occur in novels. I do not, in fact,
call these probable occurrences in every-day life, but none of the story
is probable. Jasper’s “weird seizures” are meant to lead up to
_something_. They may have been meant to lead up to the failure of the
murder and the escape of Edwin. Of course Dickens would not have treated
these incidents, when he came to make Edwin explain,—nobody else could
explain,—in my studiously simple style. The drugged Edwin himself would
remember the circumstances but mistily: his evidence would be of no value
against Jasper.
Mr. Proctor next supposes, we saw, that Drood got into touch with
Grewgious, and I have added the circumstances which might take Grewgious
to the churchyard. Next, when Edwin recovered health, he came down,
perhaps, as Datchery, to spy on Jasper. I have elsewhere said, as Mr.
Cuming Walters quotes me, that “fancy can suggest no reason why Edwin
Drood, if he escaped from his wicked uncle, should go spying about
instead of coming openly forward. No plausible unfantastic reason could
be invented.” Later, I shall explain why Edwin, if he is Datchery, might
go spying alone.
It is also urged that Edwin left Rosa in sorrow, and left blame on
Neville Landless. Why do this? Mr. Proctor replies that Grewgious’s
intense and watchful interest in Neville, otherwise unexplained, is due
to his knowledge that Drood is alive, and that Neville must be cared for,
while Grewgious has told Rosa that Edwin lives. He also told her of
Edwin’s real love of her, hence Miss Bud says, “Poor, poor Eddy,” quite
_à propos de bottes_, when she finds herself many fathoms deep in love
with Lieutenant Tartar, R.N. “‘Poor, poor Eddy!’ thought Rosa, as they
walked along,” Tartar and she. This is a plausible suggestion of Mr.
Proctor. Edwin, though known to Rosa to be alive, has no chance! But,
as to my own remark, “why should not Edwin come forward at once, instead
of spying about?” Well, if he did, there would be no story. As for “an
unfantastic reason” for his conduct, Dickens is not writing an
“unfantastic” novel. Moreover, if things occurred as I have suggested, I
do not see what evidence Drood had against Jasper. Edwin’s clothes were
covered with lime, but, when he told his story, Jasper would reply that
Drood never returned to his house on Christmas Eve, but stayed out,
“doing what was correct by the season, in the way of giving it the
welcome it had the right to expect,” like Durdles on another occasion.
Drood’s evidence, if it was what I have suggested, would sound like the
dream of an intoxicated man, and what other evidence could be adduced?
Thus I had worked out Drood’s condition, if he really was not killed, in
this way: I had supposed him to escape, in a very mixed frame of mind,
when he would be encountered by Grewgious, who, of course, could make
little out of him in his befogged state. Drood could not even prove that
it was not Landless who attacked him. The result would be that Drood
would lie low, and later, would have reason enough for disguising himself
as Datchery, and playing the spy in Cloisterham.
At this point I was reinforced by an opinion which Mr. William Archer had
expressed, unknown to me, in a newspaper article. I had described
Edwin’s confused knowledge of his own experience, if he were thoroughly
drugged, and then half strangled. Mr. Archer also took that point, and
added that Edwin being a good-hearted fellow, and fond of his uncle
Jasper, he would not bring, or let Grewgious bring, a terrible charge
against Jasper, till he knew more certainly the whole state of the case.
For that reason, he would come disguised to Cloisterham and make
inquiries. By letting Jasper know about the ring, he would compel him to
enter the vault, and then, Mr. Archer thinks, would induce him to “repent
and begin life afresh.”
I scarcely think that Datchery’s purpose was so truly honourable: he
rather seems to be getting up a case against Jasper. Still, the idea of
Mr. Archer is very plausible, and, at least, given Drood’s need of
evidence, and the lack of evidence against Jasper, we see reason good, in
a novel of this kind, for his playing the part of amateur detective.
DICKENS’S UNUSED DRAFT OF A CHAPTER
← 고전 원문 폴더
📄 고전 원문 · 영어권 · 프로젝트 구텐베르크
『The Puzzle of Dickens's Last Plot』
Andrew Lang
86,380자 · 저작권 근거: 저작자 모두 1912년 이전 사망(한국 저작권 보호기간 끝) · 원문 출처
내 자료함의 ‘📚 고전’ 글 폴더에 앞부분 2만 자가 담겨요. 회차 편집기의 ‘✦ 안드로메다 AI 이용하기 → 🖼️ 내 글·사진 분위기로 쓰기’에서 골라 이 고전의 분위기·문체를 참고해 쓸 수 있어요.